Cottagecore Has an Identity Crisis, and It's English vs. French Country
The two aesthetics we keep lumping together are actually doing completely different things. Here's what separates them.
The thing nobody tells you about English country and French country is that they are not the same aesthetic. You wouldn’t know this from Pinterest, which has spent the last five years lumping them together under the “cottagecore” umbrella and calling it a day.
Different countries. Different centuries. Different design philosophies entirely. Treating them as interchangeable is a crime against interior design history, and I say that with love, because I used to be a person who did exactly that.
I moved to the south of France three years ago thinking I was going to live out my wildflower-and-chintz fantasies in a sun-drenched stone farmhouse. What I learned, almost immediately, is that no French woman in the history of Provence has ever decorated like that. The aesthetic I had been chasing was English. I just didn’t know it yet.
So, let’s actually separate the two.
Where English country (aka cottagecore) comes from
English country, as we know it today, owes most of its visual language to a handful of surprisingly specific people. Laura Ashley in the seventies, printing ditsy florals on every piece of fabric she could get her hands on. The Bloomsbury set at Charleston Farmhouse, where Vanessa Bell and Duncan Grant painted directly onto their furniture and layered textiles like they were building a collage. The National Trust cottages dotted across the English countryside, preserved with their chintz armchairs and needlepoint cushions and framed botanical prints climbing every wall.
The aesthetic is literary. It is indoor. It is fundamentally maximalist, in the sense that the goal of a well-decorated English country room is to feel like it has been accumulating for generations.
Nothing matches on purpose. The tea set came from a grandmother. The rug was inherited from a great-aunt. The sofa has been reupholstered twice and has a quilt thrown over the arm for good measure. A bookshelf is crammed with well-worn novels, most of them Austen or Brontë or something published by Virago Press in 1985.
English country wants you inside with a book, a cup of tea, and a cat on your lap. It is cozy as a design philosophy. It is also, if you really look at it, a little bit cluttered on purpose, because a room that has been loved for a century earns that right.
Where French country comes from
French country lives in a completely different world, and that world is Provence. The farmhouses of the Luberon, the old mas tucked into the hills around Aix and Avignon, the stone cottages with blue shutters that every American thinks of when they hear the phrase “south of France.”
The aesthetic got its export moment in the seventies, when a brand called Pierre Deux started bringing those blue-and-yellow Provençal prints to American department stores, and for about fifteen years it was impossible to walk into a tasteful suburban kitchen in New Jersey without seeing a quilted placemat from the Souleiado collection.
The aesthetic is outdoor-adjacent. It was built for a climate where you spend half your life on a terrace, and the houses were designed accordingly. Cool stone floors to combat the heat. Thick walls that stay cool in summer and hold warmth in winter. Wrought-iron beds that don’t trap heat the way upholstered ones do. Linen everything, because it breathes. Terracotta pots, because they were already being made in every village. Copper pans hanging in the kitchen, because the kitchen is the heart of the house and copper looks beautiful against plaster.
French country is lean. Not minimalist exactly, because there are still baskets and ceramics and dried lavender bunches hanging from every hook, but the bones of the room are about letting the materials themselves do the talking. Stone, wood, iron, linen, terracotta. A French country room is uncluttered in a way an English country room almost never is, and the restraint is the whole point.
It wants you on a terrace with a bottle of rosé and a bowl of olives, not curled up inside with a novel. The orientation of the entire aesthetic is outward.
For the cost of a monthly chai latte, you can unlock the full Petal + Hearth experience — weekly downloads, private essays, and access to the growing Member Vault of resources designed to help you romanticize your everyday life.
The real difference, said plainly
One is Jane Austen. The other is Patricia Wells. One is a Laura Ashley floral. The other is a linen tea towel with a sprig of dried lavender folded inside. One is cozy, inherited, layered, literary. The other is sun-bleached, practical, spare, sensual.
Both of them have the same underlying value, which is a love of natural materials and slow living and craftsmanship. But the way they express that value is almost opposite. English country builds inward, piling on texture and pattern and memory until a room feels like a nest. French country strips back, letting light and space and a few beautiful objects breathe.
Neither is better. They are answers to different climates, different literatures, different ways of living.
Which one is right for you
If you love a good reading nook, a wall of framed botanicals, mismatched china, a sofa you can sink into, and the specific visual pleasure of a room that looks like someone’s grandmother has been decorating it for forty years, you are an English country person. Lean in. Start haunting estate sales for chintz armchairs and blue-and-white transferware. Plant a wild cottage garden if you have the space, or a single window box of sweet peas if you don’t.
If you prefer a room that breathes, a kitchen where copper catches the light, linen curtains that move when the window is open, and the sense that your home is oriented around the terrace or the window or the light coming through it, you are a French country person. Lean in differently. Find a good linen tablecloth. Learn which olive oil tin you like the look of. Put fewer things on your shelves and better things on your table.
Most of us, if we are honest, default to English cottagecore because it is what Pinterest serves us, and because the English aesthetic has had a much louder marketing department since the seventies.
But I will say, having lived inside the French version for three years now, that it might be the better fit for a modern life. It asks less of a small space. It makes a city apartment feel airy instead of crowded. It plays well with natural light, which most of us are desperate for. And it requires almost no shopping, because the whole ethos is that you already have enough stuff.
You can also do both. A French country kitchen with a cozy English reading corner is, genuinely, the dream. The two don’t fight as much as you’d think once you understand what each one is actually doing.
The thing I have come to love about both aesthetics, now that I can tell them apart, is that they were never really about the decorating. They were about how a home feels when someone actually lives in it. Generations of women across two countries have been quietly making their houses beautiful with whatever they had, and we’re all just reaching back, trying to learn from them.
Whether the answer is a patchwork quilt or a linen-draped bed, the moral of this story is the same. Pay attention. Choose things you love. Let the house reflect the life you are actually living, not the one you’re scrolling past.
About the Author:
Hey there! I’m Olivia, the heart behind Petal + Hearth. Originally from California, I moved to the south of France in 2023 to create a slower, more intentional life, and share the journey along the way. By day, I run the business of my dreams as a freelance copywriter. Here, I pour my love for seasonal rituals, intentional routines, and the magic of shaping a life you can truly fall in love with into every post.
Want to go deeper? Here’s how I can help:
📞 Book a 1:1 office hours session and we’ll dig into your Substack strategy together.
🪩 Founding members get a personal annual Substack audit plus monthly goal-setting Zooms and more.
✨ Get your product or service in front of my audience through a sponsored newsletter.
❤️🔥 And if you want to hang outside of your inbox, find me Instagram or LinkedIn!!
💬 Feel free to like or comment on this newsletter so more Substack users can find it! ♥️
Honestly I love both, but am probably more drawn to English cottagecore considering I'm British!!